Could California reading reforms match Mississippi’s gains? Lessons from ‘miracle’

California has spent years making changes to how schools teach children to read. Now, as new screening policies take effect and the state weighs which instructional materials to recommend, its gradual approach faces a test — can those changes add up to the gains Mississippi has seen?

Read more Sacramento airport disruptions continue; Republic FC playoff game rescheduled

Experts say some state programs have helped participating schools, but questions remain whether that piecemeal approach gives districts enough direction to improve reading statewide.

Mississippi’s fourth grade reading scores drew national attention in 2024, when the state ranked ninth in the country, up from near the bottom in 2013. The gains, often referred to as “Mississippi Miracle,” came during a period of the state’s sweeping education reforms. And it has prompted some educators and researchers to ask what California might learn from Mississippi’s experience.

On the 2024 National Assessment of Educational Progress, which tests reading in fourth and eighth grades, California ranked 39th among states and Washington, D.C., in fourth-grade reading, scoring 2 points below the national average of 214.

“California’s educational performance in general is not acceptable for an affluent state that is one of the world’s leading economies,” said Morgan Polikoff, a professor of education at the University of Southern California’s Rossier School of Education.

“I don’t think the solution is going to be all one thousand school districts in the state figuring this out on their own. That clearly is not going to be a recipe for large-scale improvement.”

Limits in adopting Mississippi’s model

Polikoff identified California’s tradition of local control and state leaders’ lack of accountability as main factors he believes contribute to the state’s lagging education performance.

California has adopted several literacy policies over the past decade, often through targeted grants serving specific schools rather than through a broad statewide overhaul.

Since the 2025-26 school year, for example, California public schools have been required under Senate Bill 114 to screen students in kindergarten through second grade annually for reading difficulties. Recently passed Assembly Bill 1454 expands the state’s role in literacy instruction by setting evidence-based standards for K-8 reading materials and educator training.

The state also provides grants to help schools hire and train literacy coaches and specialists, as well as grants to improve reading at lower performing schools. The 2026-27 state budget set $151.4 billion in total TK-12 education funding, including $350 million to extend the coaches and specialists grant program.

But California’s system leaves difficult decisions about curriculum and instruction to local educators and districts, while the state sets what Polikoff described as a low minimum bar.

“If the state puts out a list with 30 different materials, and districts adopt whatever from that list, and also self-certify their own stuff, it makes it much more difficult for you to have some centralized provision of professional learning,” Polikoff said, adding Mississippi’s narrow list of materials made it easier for the state to provide direct support.

California school districts may use instructional materials not adopted by the State Board of Education if they align with state standards and undergo a local review process.

Read more How much rain fell in Sacramento? See 72-hour rainfall totals across region

Still, experts cautioned against directly comparing Mississippi’s results and environment with California’s.

Mississippi’s approach relied in part on hiring strong literacy coaches at the state level and assigning them to struggling schools. Sarah Novicoff, a research fellow at the Public Policy Institute of California, said California’s size would make that model difficult to replicate.

“If you imagine people hired in the local Sacramento area and then being dispatched to Eureka and San Diego, and then reassigned a month later from San Diego to Fresno — that is pretty hard to imagine working well,” Novicoff said.

Novicoff said, however, California could still adapt the approach by assigning state-hired coaches to regions, allowing them to support nearby schools rather than sending them across the state.

“The literacy coaches and reading specialists grant … led to many school districts hiring more literacy coaches,” Novicoff added.

“But not all districts, even those who received the grants, were able to hire coaches because there aren’t enough trained coaches in their areas. That’s another reason why more state action to address the kind of supply problem might be needed down the line.”

What it will take to improve reading

Even setting aside comparisons with Mississippi, California has struggled to improve its own English language arts test scores. In the latest state data, just 49.3% of California students scored at the proficient or advanced levels in English language arts.

In the Sacramento region, Folsom Cordova Unified was the only one of the region’s six largest districts where a majority of students demonstrated grade-level proficiency in ELA.

Experts said California could improve students’ reading outcomes by identifying struggling readers, providing targeted interventions and giving districts clearer guidance on curriculum materials.

Novicoff said students do better if “they are identified early,” noting California screens students once a year while Mississippi three times.

Polikoff agreed on the use of screeners, and recommended “targeted and specific interventions” for students who fail to meet benchmarks.

“What California’s approach currently feels like is ‘we’re going to say to districts curriculum materials, professional development, and screeners are important, but then everything else, you’ve got to figure out,’” Polikoff said.

Read more ACC fines UNC, Louisville, announces suspensions after post-game football brawl

“I don’t think (that) makes much sense, or is a recipe that will work.”

By admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *