AI-generated summary reviewed by our newsroom.
Read our AI Policy.
- Federal prosecutors subpoenaed Sacramento County voter records before arrests.
- The records became the backbone of a dozen criminal cases in California.
- Subpoenas also went to other counties, the secretary of state and DMV.
Federal prosecutors subpoenaed records for an undisclosed number of Sacramento County voters in the days leading up to arrests and charges against a dozen Central Valley residents accused of voting illegally as noncitizens, The Sacramento Bee has learned.
The subpoena, which was dated Sept. 3, ordered county elections officials to appear before a federal criminal grand jury two weeks later. It demanded voter records for several individuals from 2021 through the present day, a redacted copy obtained by The Bee through a public records act request shows.
Similar subpoenas were also sent to other counties in the sprawling federal enforcement district that includes Sacramento, Fresno and parts of the Bay Area, court records show. In addition, prosecutors sent them to the office of California Secretary of State Shirley Weber and to the Department of Motor Vehicles, which processes thousands of voter registrations each year, court records show.
“This is extraordinary,” said Kevin Johnson, professor and former dean of the UC Davis School of Law. “I’m not aware of this ever happening in any recent cases.”
The timing of the subpoenas coincides with efforts by the federal government in advance of the Nov. 3 midterm elections to force California to set aside ballots from 20,000 people it said might be noncitizens registered to vote.
The information they produced became the backbone of a dozen criminal cases filed in the Eastern District of California, which comprises much of the Central Valley from Bakersfield to the Oregon border.
The resulting charges and arrests were then cited in other court cases, lending credence to the government’s database of possible noncitizen voters and supporting the Trump administration’s claims that immigrants were casting ballots illegally in California.
The database, its accuracy questioned by several federal judges, became a flashpoint in tensions between the administration of Republican President Donald Trump and California’s Democratic leaders. The list is the subject of several lawsuits and was used as the basis for the administration’s demand — rejected Nov. 2 by the U.S. Supreme Court — that California segregate ballots from people named on it.
Three Sacramento residents, all green-card holders, were among about 40 people in California who were named on the government’s list of possible noncitizens and criminally charged as the election drew near — a longtime nursing home employee, a 68-year-old man with a heart condition and a man whose lawyer said he was “baffled” by the case against him.
The charges are all misdemeanors, carrying a possible sentence of one year in federal prison. If convicted the individuals’ immigration status could also be affected.
Seeking information on voters
Records requested in the Sacramento County subpoena included the voters’ complete registration file, the number of times they voted and any updates or affidavits made in connection with registering to vote. It asked for information about where the people registered to vote and for their complete voting histories.
“The records requested by this subpoena are for use in a criminal investigation pending in the Eastern District of California,” it said.
County officials complied with the demand, which was sent to the office Sacramento County Registrar of Voters Hang Nguyen, spokesperson Ken Casparis said in an email to The Bee.
“That subpoena was for records, which the County provided in an appropriately redacted form,” leaving out the voters’ choices of candidates and their party affiliations, Casparis said.
Hang did not personally appear before the grand jury, he said. He did not say how many names were on the original subpoena, although the redacted area where the names were listed took up most of a page.
U.S. Attorney Eric Grant, who signed the letter accompanying the subpoena, did not comment on how the information obtained from the request was used or the number of voters whose history was sought.
“Consistent with federal law, we are required to maintain grand jury secrecy in all grand jury investigations, including with respect to any investigative tools that may or may not have been used,” Grant said in a statement to The Bee.
But the document does offer some clues.
It shows that the subpoena was requested by assistant U.S. Attorney Kevin Khasigian, who is prosecuting the Sacramento area cases against noncitizens accused of voting illegally. It requests that information also be sent to assistant U.S. Attorney Joshua Banister, who along with Khasigian is handling a dozen cases in the sprawling Central Valley federal district that includes Sacramento, Fresno and parts of the Bay Area.
Read more California man pimped his girlfriend for over a year and took $100K, prosecutors say
And it directs any questions about the subpoena to FBI Special Agent Laura Giouzelis, who conducted the investigation into at least one of the criminal cases in Sacramento. The document also asks that any emailed responses to the subpoena be sent to Giouzelis.
An affidavit submitted by Giouzelis in the case of Meryll Quirong Costi appears to reflect the information requested in the subpoena, citing “certified voter participation records” for her from the Sacramento County Registrar of Voters. The records began in 2021 and covered the years requested in the subpoena.
Certified voter participation records from the Sacramento County Registrar of Voters were also cited as evidence that Sacramento resident Juan Antonio Rivas Garcia, who holds a green card but is not a citizen, voted by mail in 2022 and 2024, court records show.
Casting a wide net
Similar demands were made in other counties, court records show.
For example, affidavits filed in connection with two Solano County cases also cite such records from the Solano County Registrar of Voters, court records show. One, filed in the case of Vallejo resident Jenalyn Stewart, includes an image of the envelope containing a provisional ballot cast in the 2025 redistricting election. It also shows a signature and handwritten address that prosecutors said were penned by Stewart.
In seeking information on voters in Fresno and Tulare Counties, prosecutors sent subpoenas to the registrar of voters there, as well as California’s Secretary of State and the DMV, court records show.
“Between September 2, 2026, and September 4, 2026, special agents with the FBI served grand jury subpoenas on the California Secretary of State, the Fresno Registrar of Voters, and the California Department of Motor Vehicles (’DMV’) seeking voter registration, voting history, and address information for Maricela Nazarin Gonzalez,” an affidavit filed with Gonzalez’ case says.
The subpoenas also requested information on Camilo Giles Jimenez of Kerman, California, records show. Jimenez was later charged with three counts of voting by an alien.
“By October 1, 2026, the FBI had received substantive responses for every subpoena served,” the affidavits say.
The wording in the subpoenas appeared designed to cast a wide net, and the counties may not have been able to produce everything that was requested, said Johnson of UC Davis.
“It makes it sound that they’re on a fishing expedition for whatever information they can dig up to use in these cases,” he said.
Still, the resulting information would allow the Justice Department to continue to pursue criminal cases against noncitizens voting illegally, he said.
When the cases were filed, the Trump administration announced them with news releases and two press conferences. The prosecutions would continue despite the passing of the midterm elections and Republican losses at the polls, Justice Department officials have told The Bee.
“The fact that they brought actions, requested documents, make it sound to me like they want to go after these cases that they brought and to the extent possible, make them showcases for the administration,” Johnson said.
Consequences for immigration status
The dozen people facing prosecution in the Eastern District have green cards, meaning that they are lawful permanent residents of the U.S. If they can prove they were confused or mistaken when registering to vote or casting ballots, their sentences on misdemeanor charges may be light or involve probation, Johnson said.
But federal law takes very seriously any falsehoods made in connection with elections, as well as regarding immigration, Johnson said. And convictions even on misdemeanor charges could carry serious consequences, including removal from the country.
He pointed to a 2021 case in which the Supreme Court declined to stop the planned deportation of a man who had 13-years earlier mistakenly checked a box on a driver’s license application saying he was a citizen.
“They could possibly be stripped of their lawful permanent resident status for committing fraud,” he said.
Read more California is suing OpenAI over automated hacking incident
