A reader, Michael Schend, responded to a story we wrote recently about a $130 national fee for electric car drivers that Congress is considering imposing as soon as December asking why Congress doesn’t consider eliminating the gas tax and adding a tax on all tire purchases instead of imposing a new EV fee to help pay for roads. We took a deeper dive to attempt to answer his questions.
Read more What are the Rams’ playoff odds with 7 games remaining?
If you have questions about anything you read in our coverage, email me at [email protected] and I’ll do my best to answer. You can also subscribe to our Cars newsletter here.
Schend said his suggestion of a new federal tax on tires would be a more equitable way to ensure all drivers are paying their fair share for road improvements, regardless of what type of powertrains their vehicles have.
“My suggestion is eliminate the gas tax and impose a national sales tax on the purchase of tires,” Schend wrote. “Drive more, pay more, drive less, pay less. Every type of car would be treated equally, gas, hybrid EV, heavy, light etc.”
The USA TODAY Cars team took a look at why Congress is looking to impose new EV fees, whether taxing tires instead of gas and EVs would be practical and what other alternatives lawmakers have considered to raise money for road projects.
Why is Congress considering an EV fee?
Congress is considering adding an EV fee because lawmakers have struggled to come up with new ways to pay for road construction as receipts from the federal gas tax that has historically funded them dwindle.
The federal government currently collects 18.4 cents per gallon on every U.S. gasoline purchase and 24.4 cents on diesel buys to help pay for road and transit construction projects, and most states also tack on their own fees. EV drivers don’t pay that tax because their vehicles don’t use gasoline.
Money collected from gas-car drivers through federal fuel taxes goes into the U.S. Department of Transportation’s Highway Trust Fund and is then distributed to states to help pay for road and transit construction projects. As cars have become more fuel-efficient and more drivers have opted for EVs and hybrids, less money per mile driven has been collected, despite increased use of roads. Lawmakers have looked for ways to close that growing gap in federal gas tax revenue.
The federal gas tax hasn’t increased since 1993, and it brings in about $40 billion a year at its current level, according to the Tax Policy Center. President Donald Trump and some lawmakers in Congress have recently proposed suspending the federal gas tax as the average price of gas hovers near $4 per gallon, according to the AAA Auto Club.
The federal government typically spends about $60 billion on transportation projects, and infrastructure advocates say that amount is just enough to maintain the nation’s roads and transit systems. Most states also levy their own gas taxes to fund local road projects.
Supporters of the proposed fee say it’s time for EV drivers to contribute to the fund that helps pay for the upkeep of the roads they use. Rep. Sam Graves, R-Missouri, who chairs the U.S. House Transportation Committee, said in a statement that the EV fee “ensures that electric vehicle owners begin paying their fair share for the use of our roads.”
EV supporters have argued that additional annual fees increase the cost of owning an electric vehicle.
“Charging a punitive fee on Americans who choose to drive electric vehicles goes against the idea of drivers paying their fair share based on their driving habits, as drivers will pay based on their drivetrain of choice and not their use of public infrastructure,” Albert Gore, who is executive director of the Zero Emission Transportation Association, which lobbies in Washington for EV-friendly policies, said in a statement.
EV supporters note that gas-car drivers only pay between $70 to $90 per year in fuel taxes, according to Consumer Reports, which is far less than Congress wants to charge plug-in vehicle owners.
How would a tire tax work?
Drivers currently pay sales taxes when they buy tires similar to the ones they pay when they purchase most other goods. The money from those tax collections usually goes to state and local coffers.
Read more 49ers’ best and worst PFF grades from 46-40 win over Cowboys
The federal gas tax and the proposed EV fee are designed to create dedicated funding sources that will help pay for U.S. road projects. The entire 18.4 cents-per-gallon that is collected for gas purchases and 24.4 cents-per-gallon on diesel goes into the Department of Transportation’s Highway Trust Fund. The only money that isn’t dedicated to roads is 20 percent of the collections that is required by law to pay for transit projects.
A potential problem with converting to a tire tax system is most people replace their tires infrequently. Most drivers decide it’s time to replace their tires when they are damaged or their tread is wearing thin, but many manufacturers recommend replacing tires between six to 10 years old, regardless of treadwear, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
So that’s potentially a half-decade or more that most drivers would pay into the system, while roads deterioration continues. Remember, there’s already an approximately $20 billion shortfall in transportation funding that lawmakers are trying to address with ideas like the EV fee.
What other alternatives has Congress considered for road funding?
Mileage fees have been floated by infrastructure supporters as a potential replacement for the gas tax before.
Vehicle miles traveled (VMT) programs tax drivers based on miles they drive on U.S. roads instead of how much gasoline they purchase. Mileage-based road tax proposals have long been controversial in U.S. transportation funding debates because critics question how the government would monitor drivers’ traveling habits without infringing on their privacy.
A number of states, such as Oregon, Utah, Hawaii, Virginia and Colorado, have adopted mileage fee programs for passenger cars, according to the Tax Foundation. But thus far Congress has been unwilling to do so.
As gas tax receipts have dwindled, Congress has resorted to transferring money into the Highway Trust Fund to make up for the shortfall rather than raise the fuel levy or adopt a controversial mileage menu.
Supporters of the current proposal note that the EV tax proposal would involve no tracking or reporting from drivers about their travels. EV owners would simply pay the $130 annual fee upon registering their vehicles each year.
Other alternatives that have been floated include increased tolling and use of high-occupancy toll lanes, congestion pricing, parking fee and indexing the federal gas tax to inflation, according to Transportation for America, which is a non-profit organization that advocates for equitable transportation policies in Washington.
According to Transportation for America, lawmakers know they need to do something soon as gas tax receipts dwindle. But there’s little agreement so far on what the best option is.
“Without a switch to alternative funding mechanisms, America’s road maintenance backlog will grow dangerously long and public transit agencies will be forced to drastically cut service,” the group said.
“Policymakers are now faced with a new challenge: how can we fund our roads without relying on gas-powered cars?” the group continued. “Any new tax structures will face challenges in providing stable revenue, incentivizing the right behavior, fairly and equitably impacting all taxpayers, and being implemented.”
Keith Laing is an automotive reporter on the National Trending Desk at USA TODAY. Contact Keith at [email protected].
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Reader asks why Congress doesn’t tax tires instead of EVs. Here’s why
Read more Stephen Curry discusses retirement following recent contract extension
Reporting by Keith Laing, USA TODAY / USA TODAY
USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect
Copyright Reuters or USA Today Network via Reuters Connect
This story was originally published November 17, 2026 at 10:59 AM.
