Should California’s high court stop Newsom’s death sentence clemency? A legal fight brews

Disagreement over Gov. Gavin Newsom’s plan to commute the sentences of the state’s condemned inmates to life in prison without the possibility of parole escalated among advocates on both sides of the issue on Tuesday, after California’s best-known constitutional law expert said a lawsuit by opponents was “frivolous.”

Read more Sutter Health merger OKed by Minnesota attorney general, with $2 billion agreement

The pointed criticism by UC Berkeley law dean Erwin Chemerinsky came a day after prosecutors and victims rights groups asked the state Supreme Court to stop Newsom’s plan, saying it violated state law.

“I have read the briefs that have been filed in opposition to this, and frankly, I think the arguments are frivolous,” Chemerinsky said at a news conference organized by supporters of the commutations.

Opponents of the governor’s move quickly shot back, saying that if their lawsuit was frivolous, the Supreme Court would not have requested more information the same day that the petition was filed.

“The Supreme Court could have just denied the writ out of hand, and they didn’t do that,” said Gregory Totten, CEO of the California District Attorneys Association and the former top prosecutor in Ventura County. “They immediately, within less than 24 hours of our filing of the writ, issued a directive.”

The competing legal analyses offered by the two sides offer a hint of how arguments over the case may play out in court on a polarizing issue for Californians.

State-sanctioned killing or justice for victims?

Newsom, who leaves office at the end of this year and is openly mulling a presidential bid, said earlier this month that he would commute the sentences of 548 inmates, some convicted of gruesome murder and torture cases dating back decades.

Opponents of the death penalty celebrated, citing the expense of pursuing capital punishment in California’s sluggish legal system and calling it state-sanctioned killing.

But Newsom’s Nov. 5 announcement drew immediate pushback from many prosecutors, who see capital punishment as an important tool to deter crime and bring comfort and a sense of justice to victims. Voters have twice in recent years rejected efforts to repeal California’s death penalty law.

On Monday, family members of murder victims, along with the California District Attorneys Association and other groups, filed a lawsuit asking the California Supreme Court to stop Newsom from commuting the sentences.

The governor’s move “horrified” victims and did not provide notice to prosecutors as required under the groups’ interpretation of state law, the groups said.

Late Monday, the state Supreme Court indicated it would consider the lawsuit by sending a letter to Newsom asking him to respond to the groups’ request for a temporary restraining order stopping the commutations, the court’s docket shows.

The governor answered on Tuesday, saying he opposed such a move.

On the books but not carried out

California has not carried out a death sentence since 2006, when Clarence Ray Allen died by lethal injection 24 years after his conviction for ordering the murders of witnesses against him in a burglary case. In 2019 Newsom declared a moratorium on executions, moving prisoners off of San Quentin’s notorious death row and dismantling the prison’s lethal injection chamber.

But the death penalty remains on the books in California, and prosecutors continue to seek capital punishment in some murder cases, triggering millions in legal and court costs and leading the number of condemned inmates to swell. The population of condemned inmates — some incarcerated since the 1970s — ballooned to around 700 before dropping over the past few years, mostly due to prisoners dying from natural causes or by suicide.

Last year, a jury in Sacramento sentenced Adel Ramos, 53, to death after he admitted shooting Tara O’Sullivan, a 26-year-old rookie police officer. California requires separate penalty trials in capital cases, which annually cost a total of about $72 million statewide, a 2024 investigation by The Sacramento Bee showed.

It was not cost but moral concerns that Newsom cited in an open letter to Californians explaining why he planned to commute the sentences.

“The people sentenced to death in California caused indescribable suffering to victims, their families, communities and our state as a whole,” Newsom wrote. “Many Californians feel that those who commit brutal crimes deserve to die. But as governor, I have concluded the state cannot morally kill them.”

Read more California prosecutor stabbed in the back while waiting to appear in a campaign ad

California law allows the governor to commute a sentence of anyone who has been convicted of a felony in connection with a single incident. But clemency for those with multiple felony convictions is only allowed if four members of the state Supreme Court agree.

As result, Newsom also sent a letter to the high court, asking the judges to review the cases of 382 condemned prisoners who had more than one felony conviction.

But the lawsuit filed by Totten’s group argued that Newsom’s actions violated the law in several ways.

Their pleading pointed to a state law enacted in 2011 — and a Supreme Court decision referencing that law — that required 10 days’ notice to prosecutors and victims before someone’s sentence could be reduced. Another law, the group said, required the governor to seek advice from the Board of Parole Hearings.

Newsom, they said, had abused the power of the executive branch by not doing so.

The lawsuit also said the governor had not properly analyzed the cases to see which ones required the Supreme Court to weigh in, leading to mistakes on both lists of inmates. Further, the lawsuit argued that by removing the death sentences, Newsom would be trampling on decisions made by juries, judges and the voters who chose to keep the death penalty on the books, they said.

On Tuesday, the high court agreed to let the groups behind the lawsuit file their own argument, known as an amicus or friend of the court brief, in connection with the governor’s request for review of the inmates with multiple felony convictions.

Reconsidering the work of judges and juries

“The core question in this case is whether the governor has abused his power,” Totten said in an interview. “That’s at the heart of this.”

Chemerinsky said he did not believe those arguments would hold up before the high court. While it is true that the death penalty remains legal and would have been imposed by a judge and jury, that does not mean a governor cannot grant clemency, he said.

Newsom, he said, had followed the rules imposed by California law by announcing his plan and writing to the Supreme Court to ask them to consider the cases of inmates with multiple felony convictions.

Elisabeth Semel, who co-directs the UC Berkeley law school death penalty clinic, disagreed with the lawsuit’s interpretation of California law requiring notice to be given before clemency. She said that the law only requires notice when the inmate is requesting clemency, not when the governor is acting on his own.

Moreover, she said, by announcing his intention before issuing the commutations, Newsom was effectively giving notice.

But Totten countered that by the time Newsom made his announcement, his mind was made up, giving prosecutors and victims no voice in the decision.

The law does require the governor to give notice when considering commutation, whether or not the inmate starts the process, he said.

“I think that’s a very self-serving reading of the statute and the law,” he said. “I just fundamentally disagree.”

The court has not set dates for hearings in either proceeding, but Newsom has asked the jurists to weigh in on the 382 inmates with multiple convictions before he leaves office at the end of the year. He has said he will not issue commutations until the legal process is complete.

Read more State worker unions say California is breaking a data law. Here’s what to know

By admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *