2 WA women say ‘hazardous’ sidewalk grate left them with brain and head injuries

Two people are suing the city of Olympia in Washington state after suffering serious injuries after they slipped on a metal utility grate on a downtown sidewalk.

Read more Republican Rep. Virginia Foxx requests recount in narrow NC congressional race

Marne Nelson, a 59-year-old woman from Lewis County, and Shelly Ann Plemmons, a 74-year-old woman from Grays Harbor County, filed a personal injury lawsuit in Thurston County Superior Court on Monday.

The grate in question is in front of The Leaning Maple restaurant at 111 Washington St. NE, which is between Fourth Avenue and State Avenue. The lawsuit alleges the city allowed Puget Sound Energy to install the “hazardous” grate and subsequently failed to address it despite receiving numerous complaints, including a previous claim for damages.

The grate does not comply with American Disabilities Act design standards, the complaint alleges, due to the orientation of the grate openings and the lack of slip resistance. The location of the grate on the sidewalk also gives pedestrians little room to avoid it, the complaint states.

“When wet, the surface of the grate becomes extremely slippery, creating a hazardous condition across the pedestrian walkway,” the complaint states.

Nelson and Plemmons are represented by attorneys James McCormick and John Hardie of Evergreen Personal Injury Counsel, a Tacoma law firm. When reached for comment, McCormick said they previously submitted tort claims, but the city denied liability.

“Currently, there is no actual plan to remove the grate nor take any steps to mitigate the hazard,” McCormick said in an emailed statement. “Our lawsuit seems to be the only action that will inspire some change. We are demanding that the grate be removed as an unconditional term of our lawsuit.”

When reached for comment Friday, city of Olympia spokesperson Brandon Chapman said the city received the lawsuit Thursday and is still reviewing the allegations. He said he could not answer any questions about the grate due to the active litigation.

PSE spokesperson Gerald Tracy declined to comment on the grate as well. He said the utility does not comment on pending litigation.

PSE is not listed as a defendant in the lawsuit.

Plemmons slipped on the grate on Dec. 17, 2025, according to the complaint filed with the court. She reportedly fell forward and struck her face on the concrete.

“As a result of the fall, Plemmons sustained serious injuries, including facial lacerations and permanent scarring and disfigurement, a head injury, visual impairment, facial bruising and swelling, numbness and abnormal sensations, and recurring headaches,” the complaint states.

On Jan. 20, Nelson visited downtown Olympia for brunch. She slipped on the grate, “fell hard on her back and struck her head on the concrete,” per the complaint.

“As a result of the fall, Nelson sustained a concussion, brain injury, and injuries to her back and hip and experienced nausea, wooziness, and unsteadiness,” the complaint states. “Her injuries required medical treatment and caused her to miss work and reduce her work hours.”

An Olympia resident named Holli Coleman slipped on the grate on Jan. 18, 2019, and fractured her ankle, according to the complaint. This person reportedly filed a $16,000 claim for damages.

The city accepted the claim and compensated the person for her injuries, per the complaint.

Read more ‘Landman’ Season 3 is coming in 2027. Cameras just rolled at a Texas football game

Another person slipped on the same grate on Jan. 23, 2019, and subsequently wrote to the city on or around Feb. 5, 2019, the complaint states. On Jan. 9, 2023, the city received a communication from another person who reported she slipped and fell on the grate earlier that month, per the complaint.

Attorneys for the plaintiffs cite public records for each of these previous communications in their complaint. They allege the city took no action to address the grate in the time between these older incidents and their clients’ falls.

“If the City had just removed the grate after Coleman’s injuries, we wouldn’t be here,” McCormick said. “Ms. Nelson and Ms. Plemmons and likely many others would not have been injured if the City had just done its job and fixed this hazard.”

The city alleged Puget Sound Energy installed the grate, according to the complaint, but the complaint alleges the city is responsible for approving the grate. McCormick said they are suing the city and not PSE because the city has the ultimate duty to maintain sidewalks in a safe condition for pedestrians.

“The City allowed the grate to persist,” McCormick said. “The City took no steps to compel nor even ask PSE to remove the hazard.”

McCormick said they may add PSE to the lawsuit if the city provides an adequate factual basis for liability on PSE.

After the plaintiffs filed claims for damages, PSE reported that they were working to remove and replace the grate, but there was no confirmed date for this work, per the complaint.

The complaint states PSE and the city of Olympia inspected the grate on Oct. 14, but “neither entity was willing to take any steps to mitigate the hazardous conditions of the grate” prior to its eventual removal.

Until the grate is removed, McCormick said the city could at least apply a non-skid coating to the grate, barricade the grate to prevent pedestrians from walking on it or post warnings around the grate.

“Any of these options would be better than doing nothing and would likely help prevent further injuries,” McCormick said.

The plaintiffs are requesting the court order the city to pay “general and special damages in an amount to be proven at trial” as well as the plaintiffs’ costs and attorney fees.

The tort claims filed for Nelson and Plemmons as a precursor to the lawsuit each asked for $1 million.

McCormick said they will ultimately accept whatever a jury awards.

The case has been assigned to Thurston County Superior Court Judge Kelly Wood. A trial date has yet to be set.

This story was originally published November 17, 2026 at 5:30 AM with the headline “2 WA women say ‘hazardous’ sidewalk grate left them with brain and head injuries.”

Read more Trump administration subpoenaed Sacramento County voter info, built criminal cases

By admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *