AI-generated summary reviewed by our newsroom.
Read our AI Policy.
- Mary Fitzmaurice faces a murder charge in the death of her father, Paul Fitzmaurice.
- Georgia Fitzmaurice faces accessory and conspiracy charges.
- Judge Jeffrey Penney postponed their arraignment until Dec. 4 and denied bail.
The wife and daughter of a murdered Sacramento County man whose severed head was found in Foresthill made their first appearance Thursday in Placer Superior Court, as prosecutors revealed additional details as they formally charged both defendants in connection to the slaying.
Read more Shaken by ICE actions, another California city moves to limit access to its property
Mary Elizabeth Fitzmaurice, 45, is accused of murder in the death of her father, Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., a 73-year-old retired staff environmental scientist for the California Department of Public Health. Georgia Gwenn Fitzmaurice, 75, is accused of being an accessory in the 2022 death of her husband.
In a criminal complaint filed Thursday morning, prosecutors allege the daughter killed her father with the use of “a dangerous and deadly weapon” at some point between Sept. 16 and Sept. 28, 2022, in Citrus Heights.
The prosecutors also allege Fitzmaurice’s wife and daughter then dismembered his body in Citrus Heights and placed his head, torso, arms and legs into six garbage bags that were loaded into the daughter’s vehicle. The two then headed to Foresthill and left the garbage bags at various locations in forestland, according to the allegations listed in the criminal complaint.
The man’s severed head was found four years ago, but the rest of his body has not been found. It’s unclear what type of weapon was used to kill Fitzmaurice, it’s not listed in the complaint.
Placer DA says investigators know manner of death
Placer County District Attorney Morgan Gire said his prosecutors reviewed all the evidence collected in this homicide investigation, along with witness statements, before deciding what criminal charges to file in this case. He declined to say specifically what weapon is believed to have been used to kill Fitzmaurice.
“We’ve determined that Mary was the one who inflicted the fatal blows to Mr. Fitzmaurice and that Gwen was the one who assisted her in disposing of Mr. Fitzmaurice’s body,” Gire told reporters. “I will just say, generally, we recovered the head of Mr. Fitzmaurice, and injuries sustained to that head can lead us to believe the manner in which he died.”
Placer County sheriff’s investigators on Tuesday served a search warrant at the Citrus Heights home where the Fitzmaurices lived four years ago. Investigators spent most of the day at the Lichen Drive home, where the homicide victim’s wife and daughter still lived, searching for evidence. They were arrested later that same day and booked at the Placer County Jail.
Domestic violence charges could be added
The mother and her daughter appeared for their arraignment hearing Thursday afternoon. Judge Jeffrey Penney granted the defense attorneys’ request to postpone the arraignment until Dec. 4. He ordered both women to remain in custody without bail.
Deputy District Attorney Robert Lopez told the judge it’s possible domestic violence charges will be added to the complaint in the case’s next court hearing. The judge granted the prosecutor’s request and approved orders for the defendants to not try to communicate with the victim’s family. Such orders are typical in a case of an alleged violent crime.
After Thursday afternoon’s hearing, Gire spoke to reporters outside the court. He said a majority of the evidence was collected in this case in the past 72 hours as a result of the Citrus Heights search warrant and additional statements given to investigators.
“I would say there’s a good chance that some charges are added between now and (trial), but I can’t say for certain at this point,” Gire said.
Prosecutors formally charged Mary Fitzmaurice with murder in her father’s death, along with the deadly weapon special allegation enhancement. Georgia was charged with being an accessory after the fact in her husband’s death.
Read more Imagine biking from Folsom to Freeport. State, local leaders plan to link river trails
The mother and daughter were charged with criminal conspiracy based on allegations of Fitzmaurice’s murder, dismembering and disposing his body and collecting his Social Security and CalPERS pension benefits in the four years since his death. The mother also faces two felony counts of grand theft.
The cold case investigation began Sept. 28, 2022, when deputies responded to the discovery of a severed human head found in a trash bag in the Todd Valley area of Foresthill. Sheriff’s officials said investigators at the time could not identify the victim due to the state of decomposition. They also could not link the victim to any outstanding missing persons or homicide cases that matched the circumstances.
Victims remains not found at his home
On Wednesday, Placer County Sheriff Wayne Woo said investigators did not find any of Fitzmaurice’s remains on Tuesday at the Citrus Heights home.
An autopsy was conducted, and the victim’s skull was sent to California State University, Chico. There, forensic experts developed a preliminary age and race profile and created an artist’s rendering of the victim, sheriff’s officials said. Detectives used that information to search for a possible match among missing persons cases, but they didn’t find a match.
Woo said the victim’s DNA also was entered into a national database but no matches were found. In January 2024, investigators sent the victim’s DNA to Texas-based Othram Labs for forensic genetic genealogy testing. Sheriff’s officials said analysts at the private lab developed a genealogical profile that helped identify possible distant relatives of the victim.
Othram Labs found a potential distant relative. FBI agents in Sacramento then worked with sheriff’s detectives with interviews of distant relatives and obtaining DNA samples from them for comparison.
Woo said they found a DNA match with relatives in Idaho and identified Fitzmaurice as the homicide victim. He said Fitzmaurice had been estranged from his relatives and that they had been told by his wife and daughter that he was still alive and suffering from drug abuse.
The sheriff said the wife and daughter told Fitzmaurice’s relatives that he was “a recluse, and he would disappear for days at a time. That he was very well still alive and would come back to the house every week or so and stay for a couple of days.”
Detectives later learned Fitzmaurice was never reported missing; he was last known to be living at the Lichen Drive home with his wife and daughter in Citrus Heights.
Woo said the detectives also learned that had kept up “a facade” to family and friends that Fitzmaurice was still alive as they were still receiving his Social Security benefits and his CalPERS pension. Fitzmaurice’s monthly gross pension through CalPERS is $7,893.26, according to the California Public Employees’ Retirement System, the public pension fund for state workers.
In the criminal complaint, prosecutors allege that Fitzmaurice’s wife and daughter had been telling their friends and family that he was still alive through Tuesday, that Georgia Fitzmaurice told her husband’s family on Nov. 4 that he was still alive, that Mary Fitzmaurice told a sheriff’s detective her father was still alive during a Nov. 11 interview, and that Georgia told two sheriff’s deputies her husband was still alive Tuesday — the same day they were searching her Citrus Heights home.
Read more Sacramento’s first 3D-printed ADU is a family labor of love. ‘We’re home’
This story was originally published November 19, 2026 at 3:56 PM.
