Daughter, wife arrested in 2022 death of Citrus Heights man whose head was severed

Key Takeaways

Key Takeaways

AI-generated summary reviewed by our newsroom.

Read our AI Policy.

  • Detectives arrested Paul Fitzmaurice’s wife and daughter in his death.
  • Investigators identified the victim through forensic genetic genealogy and DNA.
  • Authorities said the mother and daughter kept collecting his Social Security and CalPERS.

Placer County sheriff’s detectives arrested the daughter and wife of a murdered 73-year-old Sacramento County man whose severed head was found four years ago in Foresthill but had never been reported missing.

Read more Woodland council favoring appointment over election to fill departing Vega’s seat

Mary Elizabeth Fitzmaurice, 45, was arrested on suspicion of murder, and her mother Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, 75, was arrested on suspicion of being an accessory in the death of Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., authorities announced Wednesday at a news conference.

“Yesterday, we served a search warrant, and I’m pleased to announce that we arrested both Gwenn and Mary for Paul’s murder,” Placer County Sheriff Wayne Woo told reporters.

Sheriff’s investigators on Tuesday served a search warrant at the Citrus Heights home where the Fitzmaurices lived four years ago. Investigators spent most of the day at the Lichen Drive home, where the homicide victim’s wife and daughter still lived, searching for evidence.

Fitzmaurice was a staff environmental scientist for the California Department of Public Health before he retired in 2010, according to CalPERS.

The cold case investigation began Sept. 28, 2022, when deputies responded to the discovery of a severed human head found in a trash bag in the Todd Valley area of Foresthill. Sheriff’s officials said investigators at the time could not identify the victim due to the state of decomposition. They also could not link the victim to any outstanding missing persons or homicide cases that matched the circumstances.

On Wednesday, the sheriff said authorities have never found the rest of Fitzmaurice’s body. He also said investigators did not find any of Fitzmaurice’s remains on Tuesday at the Citrus Heights home.

An autopsy was conducted, and the victim’s skull was sent to California State University, Chico. There, forensic experts developed a preliminary age and race profile and created an artist’s rendering of the victim, sheriff’s officials said. Detectives used that information to search for a possible match among missing persons cases, but they didn’t find a match.

Woo said the victim’s DNA also was entered into a national database but no matches were found. Detectives continued to attempt to identify the victim using all available law enforcement resources.

In January 2024, investigators sent the victim’s DNA to Othram Labs for forensic genetic genealogy testing. Sheriff’s officials said analysts at the private lab developed a genealogical profile that helped identify possible distant relatives of the victim.

Othram Labs found a potential distant relative. That’s when agents at the FBI Sacramento Field Office offered their help in the investigation to identify the homicide victim, Woo said. The FBI agents worked with sheriff’s detectives with interviews of distant relatives and obtaining DNA samples from them for comparison.

Read more UC Davis Health selects new CEO, will pay him $1.45 million a year

“Every life is precious. Every family deserves to feel safe in our home,” FBI Sacramento Special Agent in Charge Brian Tosh told reporters. “The success of this operation shows what we can achieve together.”

Woo said they found a DNA match with relatives in Idaho and identified Fitzmaurice as the homicide victim. He said Fitzmaurice had been estranged from his relatives, and they had been told by his wife and daughter that he was still alive and suffering from drug abuse.

The sheriff said the wife and daughter told Fitzmaurice’s relatives that he was “a recluse, and he would disappear for days at a time. That he was very well still alive and would come back to the house every week or so and stay for a couple of days.”

Detectives later learned Fitzmaurice was never reported missing; he was last known to be living at the Lichen Drive home with his wife and daughter in Citrus Heights.

Woo said the detectives also learned that had kept up “a facade” to family and friends that Fitzmaurice was still alive as they were still receiving his Social Security benefits and his CalPERS pension.

The California Public Employees’ Retirement System, the nation’s largest public pension fund for state workers, provides benefits and earned retirements. He retired as a staff environmental scientist for the California Department of Public Health, according to CalPERS. He held two management positions at the department from August 2000 through December 2010. Before that, he worked for Yolo County from December 1973 through January 2001.

Fitzmaurice’s monthly gross pension through CalPERS is $7,893.26, the agency said.

The mother and her daughter were booked Tuesday at the Placer County Jail, where they remained in custody Wednesday. Jail records show the Fitzmaurices are scheduled to appear for their arraignment hearing Thursday afternoon in Placer Superior Court.

Placer County District Attorney Morgan Gire, who also spoke at Wednesday’s news conference, said his office had not yet formally filed criminal charges against the Fitzmaurices. He said his prosecutors were in the process of reviewing all the information in the investigation to determine the appropriate charges to file.

“At this point, we anticipate filing murder charges against Mary for directly causing the death of Paul,” Gire said. “And we will continue to evaluate the investigation to determine if additional charges related to the murder on behalf of Gwenn are appropriate, as well as additional charges related the collecting of those (Social Security and pension) benefits.”

Read more Daughter, wife arrested in 2022 death of Citrus Heights man whose head was severed

The Bee’s Corey Schmidt contributed to this story.

This story was originally published November 18, 2026 at 1:38 PM.

By admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *