A Benton City winery employee’s trial for allegedly raping a teen was derailed earlier this week after prosecutors didn’t turn over information about a witness.
Read more Ex-UC Davis fire chief pleads no contest in Yolo County felony embezzlement case
Now prosecutors may face fines after repeated errors caused a mistrial in the case against Jose Marcelo-Bustos. The prosecutors didn’t turn over notes from the interview with the victim before the trial.
Marcelo-Bustos is accused of luring a Pasco girl to a winery and raping her. He is charged with three counts of second-degree rape, three counts of third-degree rape of a child and a single count of first-degree rape of a child.
“The rules are simple,” defense attorney Scott Johnson told the Tri-City Herald. “When prosecutors meet with their witness and learn new information, they have to tell the defense what the witness said.”
Defense attorneys didn’t learn about an interview the prosecutors did with the victim until realizing testimony didn’t match. This came after weeks of testimony where prosecutors ignored pretrial motions, Johnson said.
When Johnson demanded the notes, he was told that they were work product. The judge reviewed the notes privately before handing them over to the defense attorneys.
When defense attorneys reviewed the material they found several differences between what was in the notes and what was said during the trial. Prosecutors claimed in motions that there weren’t any differences between what the victim testified to and what was presented at trial.
But Judge Jackie Shea-Brown disagreed, saying the problems were severe enough to warrant a new trial. She also took the unusual step of ordering a hearing on sanctions for the prosecutor’s office.
In her 37 years with the clerk’s office, Benton County Clerk Josie Delvin said it was first time she has seen a judge take these steps. She is asking for the prosecutor’s office to pay $8,500 in jury costs.
While Shea-Brown plans to have a hearing on sanctions, she didn’t find that the errors were made in bad faith, Prosecutor Eric Eisinger said.
Prosecutors are already lining up another trial for Marcelo-Bustos. A pre-trial hearing is scheduled for Nov. 30.
Read more Two rescued from vehicle stuck in snowbank on remote Northern California road
Johnson pointed out that Marcelo-Bustos has been in jail since March 2024 while he waited for a trial and is presumed to be innocent.
“Because of the State’s conduct, three weeks of trial were wasted, he now faces a second trial, and the taxpayers of Benton County will pay for both,” Johnson said. “We have asked the court to dismiss the case, and we will keep pressing for that.”
Rape at a Benton City winery
Marcelo-Bustos is accused of contacting a Pasco teen through SnapChat while posing as a 16-year-old boy. The teen got into a fight with her parents and asked Marcelo-Bustos to pick her up on March 14, 2024.
He took her to the winery where he was the cellar master, and when she asked to leave, he allegedly assaulted her, made her drink wine and allegedly attacked her again after she passed out.
At the time, Marcelo-Bustos was out of jail on his own recognizance pending a Yakima County trial for raping an elementary school girl he knew about 15 years earlier.
Interview before the trial
The problems surrounded an interview with the victim that happened days before the trial began. During the interview she provided different information compared to what was said during other points of the investigation, according to a defense motion to dismiss the case.
The defense proceeded through most of the three weeks of the case without ever getting a chance to see the notes from the interview, the defense said. They pointed out that the prosecutors set out to ask questions that hadn’t been asked before.
Prosecutors responded by saying that the defense attorneys were taking the statement “I will be asking pointed questions and asking questions law enforcement and the hospital didn’t ask you” out of context.
“(Prosecutors) started that meeting trying to gauge (the victims’) mental health leading up to the trial, and into testifying, as her family had told law enforcement at the hospital that she suffers from panic attacks,” Deputy Prosecutor Holai Holbrook said in her response to the motion.
Read more Teen collapsed in gym class. CPR didn’t start for 8 minutes, lawsuit says in California
