Scott Erickson asks judge for new trial on damages in fatal crash case

Former Major League Baseball player Scott Erickson has asked a judge for a new trial, calling the damages awarded in a lawsuit over a 2020 crash excessive and unprecedented.

Read more Rams defense had its best performance in nearly 50 years on Sunday

The Iskander family filed the wrongful death suit against Rebecca Grossman, convicted of second-degree murder in the crash, and Erickson, her then-boyfriend who also was on the road at the time. Mark and Jacob Iskander, 11 and 8, were killed in a Westlake Village crosswalk six years ago.

The boys were hit by a vehicle while crossing Triunfo Canyon Road with their mom and younger brother. Witnesses said they saw and heard vehicles racing toward them.

The civil trial against Grossman and Erickson was heard in a Van Nuys courtroom earlier this year. The jury reached an initial verdict, finding both Grossman and Erickson to blame in the boys’ deaths and awarding the Iskander family $176 million in compensatory damages. Jurors later awarded an additional $22 million in punitive damages, including $1.17 million against Erickson.

Last month, Erickson’s attorney asked the judge for a new trial, saying Erickson acknowledged the jury found that he shared responsibility for the boys’ deaths and the motion did not contest liability. But his attorney described the compensatory award as unprecedented. It would leave Erickson destitute many times over, his attorneys argued, saying the court’s intervention was necessary.

The case was the sort “where passion and prejudice” naturally run high and the Iskanders’ attorney “fanned the flames” in closing statements, according to the October motion.

The Iskanders’ attorney, however, said a large verdict alone does not compel a conclusion that the award came from passion or prejudice. The motion should be denied, according to Andrew Owen, one of the family’s lawyers.

“Every indicator here points the other way: unrebutted evidence of harm, careful instructions, and a jury that reviewed every side’s numbers and adopted none of them,” Owen wrote in opposition to Erickson’s motion.

Owen described the award as measured, saying the verdict compensates three plaintiffs for losses from the violent deaths of two children. It also compensates the boys’ mom and brother the serious emotional distress of nearly being killed themselves and then watching the aftermath, according to the document.

Crash kills two young boys

On Sept. 29, 2020, Grossman, cofounder of the Grossman Burn Foundation, and Erickson were driving in separate vehicles toward her house near Westlake Lake. They had drinks earlier and planned to meet at the home to watch the presidential debate.

Read more Hot Celtics strive to slow down Franz Wagner, Magic

During the civil trial, the Iskanders’ attorney said they raced toward the intersection after drinking and didn’t stop when the two boys were struck. Grossman and Erickson sped past people biking and walking, Grossman, in a white SUV, driving more than 73 mph in a 45 mph zone, the lawyer said.

Erickson, in a black SUV, drove through the crosswalk without hitting the boys, according to witnesses and the former MLB pitcher himself. Nancy Iskander, the boys’ mom, grabbed her youngest son, the one closest to her, and dove out of the path of his vehicle.

She looked up and saw the white SUV pass the spot where Mark and Jacob had been, the boys’ mom has testified. Grossman, now 63, was convicted in 2024 of second-degree murder and other charges stemming the crash.

Grossman was sentenced to 15 years to life on each of two murder counts and three years on hit-and-run driving; all to run concurrently. She is currently at the California Institution for Women in Chino.

A hearing is scheduled on Erickson’s motion for later this month. His attorneys also asked the judge to cancel all punitive damages against their client. The compensatory damages alone wipe him out and leave Erickson unable to pay any punitive damages, his lawyer said.

The Iskanders’ attorney asked the court to deny the motion. The jury heard substantial evidence of Erickson’s financial condition, applied the ability-to-pay instruction that Erickson requested and returned an award tailored to his resources and the gravity of his conduct, the family’s attorney stated.

Cheri Carlson is a reporter for the Ventura County Star. Reach her at [email protected].

This article originally appeared on Ventura County Star: Scott Erickson asks judge for new trial on damages in fatal crash case

Read more Wizards coach demands ‘commitment’ from players against Grizzlies

Reporting by Cheri Carlson, Ventura County Star / Ventura County Star

USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

Copyright Reuters or USA Today Network via Reuters Connect

This story was originally published November 16, 2026 at 5:30 AM.

By admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *