With the University of California racing to make a decision on standardized testing requirements in admissions, dozens of students gathered outside the Board of Regents meeting Tuesday to oppose the return of tests such as the SAT.
Read more Sacramento International Airport parking rates are going up. Here’s what to know
Since June, when thousands of UC faculty from science, technology, engineering and mathematics disciplines signed an open letter calling for the reinstatement of tests such as the SAT and ACT due to widening gaps in math ability among their first-year students, the issue has become the university’s biggest question this year.
As the university’s twin goals of excellence and access come up against each other, faculty have spoken, lawmakers and higher education experts have weighed in, and administrators have expedited their review process to settle the debate as soon as possible.
Now, university students are asking decision-makers to pay attention to their concerns about racial and social disparities they say it would reintroduce into the undergraduate admissions process.
“We know that standardized testing deepens racial inequality and socio-economic barriers,” said Candice Phan, president of the University of California Student Association which represents student governments across the system, at the news conference.
“Testing closes the doors on students from communities of color and low-income backgrounds, and that is UC breaking its promise of being an engine of social mobility. If the UC really cares about making sure students are prepared for academic rigor and success, then how come tutoring and support services are being cut?”
Phan urged the university to invest in student support and coordinate more closely with the K-12 system instead of “trying to address academic preparedness issues by limiting access.” Behind her, students held signs that said “Keep the UC test-free.”
The UC system removed the use of SAT and ACT test scores in admissions in 2020 over equity concerns — a decision that STEM faculty now say has created a student body that is unprepared for college math.
At that time, an 18-member Standardized Testing Task Force convened by the Academic Senate had recommended that the use of SAT and ACT tests be continued until a UC-specific assessment could be developed. Then-president Janet Napolitano advised the Board of Regents to phase them out anyway, and the standardized test requirements were removed beginning in fall 2021. In the months after, the UC neither created a new test nor approved the inclusion of a different assessment in its admissions policy.
In the years since, the university has seen a marked rise in freshman applications. The UC also just registered all-time highs in its timely graduation rates across the system, disputing the narrative of poor academic results.
Still, data shows that more first-year students are failing introductory math courses now than six years ago when the university moved to a test-blind admissions process. Supporters of standardized testing see the data as proof of their case while critics suggest the math problem has larger roots and needs more comprehensive solutions.
José Aguilar, a UC Berkeley Ph.D. student and former public high school math teacher, said Tuesday that a test score could not capture students’ potential, aspirations and dreams.
As a teacher in Los Angeles, he said he had the honor of teaching “bright, young Black and Latina Californians who imagine themselves as diverse doctors, engineers, teachers and scientists.” He had also seen firsthand, he said, the “deeply segregated, unequal and unjust” way in which the education system determines opportunities for students even before they apply to college.
Read more Rancho Cordova approves sidewalk repairs at 39 locations. See where work is planned
“We cannot talk about merit without talking about opportunity, and we cannot talk about college readiness without talking about the conditions in which our students are expected to become college ready,” Aguilar said. “ If you’re concerned about students struggling in college mathematics, the solution should not be to measure students again. It should be to prepare them and support them better.”
The students were joined by leaders from nonprofits including the Campaign For College Opportunity, Just Equations and EdTrust-West in advocating against the tests. Several other current students delivered similar messages during public comment at the Board of Regents meeting.
Two researchers, two conclusions
Inside the boardroom, the UC regents heard from two experts on their recent research examining the relationship between SAT and ACT scores, high school grades and first-year college performance. These presentations at board meetings are a part of the university’s comprehensive review before the regents make a final decision next year.
John Friedman, professor at Brown University, presented his research concluding SAT and ACT scores predicted first-year college grades more strongly than high school GPA, when students’ race, gender and socioeconomic status were held constant. Friedman used data from 12 “Ivy Plus” selective universities for this research.
Several highly selective schools, including Harvard University and Stanford University, recently reinstated their test score requirements after removing them a few years ago due to pandemic-related disruptions.
Acknowledging large differences in standardized test scores across different demographic groups, Friedman said that was true of many measures of educational progress and not unique to the SAT and ACT. Friedman concluded those tests did not have inherent biases but were reflecting underlying disparities.
UC Berkeley professor Jesse Rothstein, on the other hand, said that SAT scores did help “modestly” in predicting first-year college grades but at a direct cost in access to students from underrepresented groups.
He said the SAT’s predictive advantage was a result of its ability to identify advantaged students. This advantage diminished, he said, when students’ backgrounds and high schools were taken into account. His research was based on data from the UC system in the 1990s and 2015.
Since the UC dropped the SAT requirement, he said the system’s most selective campuses — Berkeley, Los Angeles and San Diego — had admitted more diverse student bodies. Finally, he cautioned against reinstating the test requirement the way several Ivy League schools have recently done.
“The UC is not an Ivy League school,” Rothstein said. “It’s a unique engine for social mobility that does something that the Ivy League schools don’t even try to do. UC tries to provide access to students that the Ivy League schools just don’t try to. That’s an important part of our mission and it’s one of the reasons I’m proud to be at the University of California.”
Next steps for admissions requirements decision
While the board expands its knowledge, the Academic Senate — primarily through its Board of Admissions and Relations with Schools — is leading the university’s review of admissions policy and will develop recommendations based on months of research, data and consultation with stakeholders. Its recommendations will be considered by the university president and reviewed by the Board of Regents for a final decision. The regents have asked for a policy recommendation no later than June.
For now, the UC system is urging prospective students to prepare applications based on current undergraduate admissions requirements. The soonest any change in policy can go into effect is for students applying for fall 2028 admission.
Read more City is closing its ‘Jungle’ homeless camp one section at a time in Washington state
